Types of Borrowing
This sub‑topic covers the various types of borrowing available to individuals and entities in India, their characteristics, and regulatory considerations. Understanding these classifications helps candidates answer questions on loan structures, risk assessment, and compliance in the NISM Series X‑A exam. The content links borrowing types to debt‑management strategies discussed in the chapter.
Learning Objectives
- 1Identify and differentiate between secured and unsecured borrowing.
- 2Classify borrowing instruments as short‑term or long‑term and recognise typical examples.
- 3Explain key cost concepts such as interest calculation and Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR).
- 4Recall regulatory guidelines governing borrowing under RBI and SEBI.
Broad Classification of Borrowing
Borrowing can be broadly split into two dimensions – security (secured vs unsecured) and tenure (short‑term vs long‑term). The security dimension reflects whether the lender has a claim on specific assets if the borrower defaults. The tenure dimension reflects the period over which repayment is expected.
In the Indian context, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) defines short‑term borrowing as credit that matures within 12 months, whereas long‑term borrowing extends beyond one year. Both dimensions often overlap; for example, a secured term loan is long‑term, while an unsecured overdraft is short‑term.
Exam questions frequently test your ability to map a given instrument (e.g., cash credit, debenture) to its correct classification. Mis‑classifying an instrument leads to loss of marks, especially when the question asks for “primary purpose” or “collateral requirement”.
- Security dimension – Secured (collateral‑backed) vs Unsecured (no collateral).
- Tenure dimension – Short‑term (≤12 months) vs Long‑term (>12 months).
Students often equate “secured” with “long‑term”. While many long‑term loans are secured, short‑term loans can also be secured (e.g., hypothecated inventory). Always check both dimensions separately.
Secured Borrowing
A secured loan is one where the borrower pledges an asset as collateral. If the borrower defaults, the lender can enforce the security and recover dues by selling the asset.
Common secured instruments in India include mortgage loans (real‑estate as security), lease financing (equipment lease), hypothecation of inventory or receivables, and debentures issued against specific assets. Secured borrowing generally attracts lower interest rates because the lender’s risk is mitigated.
For the NISM exam, remember that the presence of collateral is the defining feature, not the loan’s purpose or tenure. Questions may ask you to identify the security type based on a scenario, such as “a bank lends against a borrower’s warehouse”.
- Mortgage loan – real‑estate pledged; typical tenure 5‑20 years.
- Lease financing – equipment as security; often structured as a hire‑purchase.
Unsecured Borrowing
An unsecured loan does not involve any specific asset as collateral. The lender relies on the borrower’s creditworthiness, cash‑flow profile, and reputation.
Typical unsecured instruments include personal loans, credit‑card facilities, overdraft limits without hypothecation, and unsecured corporate bonds. Because the lender bears higher risk, interest rates are usually higher than comparable secured loans.
Exam‑wise, the key is to spot the absence of collateral language. A question describing “no asset pledged” or “based purely on credit rating” signals an unsecured borrowing type.
- Personal loan – individual credit, no asset pledged.
- Credit‑card facility – revolving unsecured credit up to a limit.
Short‑Term Borrowing Instruments
Short‑term borrowing addresses immediate working‑capital needs and is usually repaid within a year. The RBI classifies these as “cash credit”, “overdraft”, “working‑capital term loan”, and “commercial paper”.
Cash credit (CC) and overdraft (OD) are revolving facilities where the borrower can draw up to an approved limit against inventory or receivables. Commercial paper (CP) is an unsecured, discount‑based instrument issued by corporates for up to 364 days.
In exam scenarios, focus on the maturity horizon and the purpose (e.g., financing inventory). Short‑term instruments often have variable interest rates linked to the repo rate.
- Cash Credit (CC) – short‑term working‑capital loan, usually secured by inventory.
- Commercial Paper (CP) – unsecured, short‑term debt instrument for corporates.
Long‑Term Borrowing Instruments
Long‑term borrowing supports capital‑expenditure projects, infrastructure financing, or strategic acquisitions. Typical instruments include term loans, term loans with amortisation, debentures, bonds, and mortgage loans.
Term loans are usually disbursed in a lump sum and repaid in equal instalments (EMI) over several years. Debentures may be secured or unsecured and can be listed on stock exchanges, subject to SEBI regulations.
For the NISM exam, remember the tenure (greater than 12 months) and the repayment structure (fixed EMI vs bullet repayment). Questions may ask you to calculate the interest component using simple interest for a short‑term loan or to identify the correct instrument for a 10‑year infrastructure project.
- Term Loan – fixed tenure, EMI repayment, often secured.
- Debenture – debt instrument, may be secured or unsecured, listed under SEBI.
Comparison of Short‑Term and Long‑Term Borrowing
| Feature | Short‑Term Borrowing | Long‑Term Borrowing |
|---|---|---|
| Maturity | ≤ 12 months | > 12 months |
| Primary Purpose | Working‑capital, inventory financing | Capital expenditure, asset acquisition |
| Collateral Requirement | Often secured (e.g., inventory) but can be unsecured | Usually secured (property, plant) |
| Typical Instruments | Cash credit, overdraft, commercial paper | Term loan, debenture, mortgage loan |
| Interest Rate Trend | Variable, linked to repo rate | Fixed or semi‑fixed, lower than short‑term |
Cost of Borrowing – Simple Interest
Many short‑term loans in India are quoted on a simple‑interest basis. Simple interest (SI) is calculated only on the principal amount, not on accumulated interest.
The formula is widely used in NISM questions that provide principal (P), annual rate of interest (R) in percent, and time (T) in years. Remember to keep the time unit consistent with the rate.
Exam tip: If the loan tenure is expressed in months, convert it to years before applying the formula, or adjust the rate to a monthly basis.
Where:
P= Principal amount in rupeesR= Annual rate of interest in percentT= Time in yearsWorked Example
Given P = 10000, R = 8, T = 3: Step 1: SI = (10000 \times 8 \times 3) / 100 Step 2: SI = 2400 Verification: (10000 \times 8 \times 3) / 100 = 2400.
NISM questions on cash credit or overdraft explicitly state “simple interest”. Using the compound‑interest formula will give a wrong answer and cost marks.
Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR)
The Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) measures a borrower’s ability to meet debt obligations from operating earnings. It is a key underwriting metric for both secured and unsecured loans.
DSCR is calculated as Net Operating Income (NOI) divided by total Debt Service (principal + interest) due in the same period. A DSCR greater than 1 indicates sufficient cash flow, while a DSCR below 1 signals potential default risk.
In the NISM exam, you may be asked to interpret a DSCR value or to compute it given NOI and debt service figures. Remember that the ratio is unit‑less; both numerator and denominator must be for the same time horizon (usually annual).
Where:
NOI= Net Operating Income in rupees per yearDebt Service= Total annual principal repayment plus interestWorked Example
Given NOI = 150000, Debt Service = 100000: Step 1: DSCR = 150000 / 100000 Step 2: DSCR = 1.5 Verification: 150000 / 100000 = 1.5.
Average Interest Rates for Common Borrowing Types (India, 2023‑24)
Scenario
Rohit runs a textile SME that needs Rs. 5,00,000 to purchase raw material for a 6‑month production cycle. He can either obtain a cash‑credit facility (secured by inventory) at 12% p.a. simple interest or a 1‑year term loan (secured by machinery) at 9% p.a. simple interest.
Solution
Calculate the interest cost for each option. Cash Credit: SI = (5,00,000 × 12 × 0.5) / 100 = Rs. 30,000. Term Loan: SI = (5,00,000 × 9 × 1) / 100 = Rs. 45,000. Although the term loan has a lower annual rate, the cash‑credit cost is lower for the 6‑month need because interest is charged only for half a year.
Conclusion
For short‑term working‑capital requirements, a cash‑credit facility often yields lower total interest despite a higher annual rate. The exam tests this nuance of matching tenure with cost.
Regulatory Framework for Borrowing
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) governs most borrowing activities through its Master Direction on Loans and Advances. Key provisions include caps on cash‑credit limits relative to inventory, mandatory security valuation, and periodic reporting of loan‑to‑value ratios.
For listed companies issuing debentures or bonds, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) prescribes disclosure norms, credit rating requirements, and investor protection measures under the SEBI (Issue of Capital and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations.
Exam candidates should remember that RBI rules apply to banks and NBFCs, while SEBI regulations become relevant when the borrowing instrument is a marketable security. Questions may ask which regulator oversees a corporate bond issue versus a bank overdraft.
⭐Exam Takeaways
- Secured borrowing involves collateral; unsecured borrowing relies solely on creditworthiness.
- Short‑term loans mature within 12 months and are used for working‑capital; long‑term loans exceed 12 months for capital projects.
- Simple interest = (P × R × T) / 100; ensure time is expressed in years to match the annual rate.
- DSCR = NOI ÷ Debt Service; a ratio >1 indicates adequate cash flow to service debt.
- RBI regulates bank‑driven borrowing; SEBI regulates marketable debt securities such as debentures and bonds.
- Interest rates for secured loans are typically lower than for unsecured loans; short‑term rates often track the repo rate.
- When evaluating borrowing options, match the instrument’s tenure with the cash‑flow need to minimise total interest cost.
Practice Questions
8 questions on Types of Borrowing
What is the defining feature of a secured loan?
According to the RBI, a borrowing that matures in 10 months is classified as?
Which of the following instruments is an unsecured short‑term borrowing option?
A company borrows Rs 200,000 at an annual simple interest rate of 10% for 9 months. What is the interest payable?
Rohit’s SME can choose cash‑credit at 12% p.a. for 6 months or a term loan at 9% p.a. for 12 months on Rs 5,00,000. Which option results in lower total interest cost?
A borrower has an annual Net Operating Income of Rs 240,000 and total annual debt service of Rs 200,000. What is the DSCR and what does it indicate?
Which regulator oversees the issuance of a corporate bond by a listed company?
A bank provides an overdraft facility without hypothecation of inventory. Based on the study material, this facility is best described as:
