7.5

Premium Discount

Premium and discount are key concepts that measure the deviation of a commodity futures price from its spot price. They help market participants gauge market expectations, cost of carry, and potential arbitrage opportunities. In the NISM Series XVI exam, understanding how to calculate and interpret premium/discount is essential for questions on clearing, settlement and risk management. This sub‑topic links directly to margin calculations and the settlement process in Indian commodity markets.

Learning Objectives

  • 1Define premium and discount in the context of commodity futures.
  • 2Apply the correct formula to calculate premium or discount percentage.
  • 3Interpret the meaning of a premium versus a discount for market participants.
  • 4Recognise the impact of premium/discount on clearing, margin and settlement under SEBI regulations.

Understanding Premium and Discount

Premium occurs when the futures price of a commodity is higher than its current spot price. This situation usually reflects the cost of carry – storage, financing and insurance – that a trader must bear to hold the commodity until delivery. In Indian commodity markets, a premium is common for non‑perishable items such as metals and energy contracts.

Discount is the opposite condition where the futures price trades below the spot price. Discounts often appear in agricultural commodities that have high seasonal harvests, because the expectation of abundant supply reduces the futures price. A discount signals that market participants anticipate lower future prices or that the cost of carry is negative.

For the NISM exam, candidates must be able to identify whether a given futures‑spot relationship represents a premium or a discount, and then compute the exact percentage. Typical exam traps involve confusing the sign of the result or mixing up numerator and denominator in the formula.

Calculation of Premium/Discount

Formula: Premium/Discount Percentage
FSS×100\frac{F - S}{S} \times 100

Where:

F= Futures price of the commodity (in rupees)
S= Spot price of the commodity (in rupees)

Worked Example

Given Spot price S = 2,000 and Futures price F = 2,100: Step 1: Compute the difference (F - S) = 2,100 - 2,000 = 100 Step 2: Divide by spot price: 100 / 2,000 = 0.05 Step 3: Multiply by 100 to get percentage: 0.05 × 100 = 5% Verification: ((2100 - 2000) / 2000) × 100 = 5%.

After calculating the percentage, a positive value indicates a premium, while a negative value indicates a discount. The magnitude tells you how far the futures price deviates from the spot price; a 5% premium means the futures price is 5% higher than the spot price. In practice, traders use this metric to decide whether to enter a futures position or to look for arbitrage opportunities.

Several market factors influence the size of the premium or discount. These include storage costs, interest rates, expected supply‑demand imbalances, and the time to contract expiry. For perishable agricultural commodities, a discount may widen as the harvest season approaches, whereas for metals a premium may increase with longer contract tenors due to higher financing costs.

Exam questions often present a futures and spot price and ask you to compute the premium/discount, then interpret the result. Remember to keep the spot price in the denominator; swapping the numbers will flip the sign and lead to a wrong answer.

ℹ️Common Sign‑Convention Mistake

Students frequently place the spot price in the numerator, producing a result that looks like a percentage change rather than a premium/discount. Always use (Futures – Spot) ÷ Spot × 100.

Impact on Clearing and Settlement

Clearing houses in India, such as MCX‑CC, require participants to post initial margin based on the futures price. A higher premium raises the futures price, which in turn increases the margin requirement. Conversely, a discount reduces the margin needed, but it may also signal higher price volatility, prompting the clearing corporation to apply a higher risk‑based margin.

During settlement, the final cash flow is determined by the difference between the futures price at expiry and the spot price on the settlement day. If a contract expires with a premium, the long position receives a cash amount equivalent to the premium, while the short position pays it. The opposite occurs for a discount.

For the NISM exam, you may be asked how premium/discount affects the variation margin or the cash‑settlement amount. The key is to link the premium/discount calculation directly to the cash flow direction for long and short positions.

Typical Premium/Discount Ranges in Indian Markets

Historical data shows that different commodity groups exhibit characteristic premium or discount patterns. Agricultural commodities such as wheat and pulses often trade at a modest discount during harvest months, whereas metals like copper and gold usually carry a small premium reflecting financing costs. Energy contracts (e.g., crude oil) can display both premium and discount depending on global inventory levels.

Understanding these typical ranges helps candidates eliminate unrealistic answer choices in multiple‑choice questions. For instance, a 20% premium on a gold futures contract would be highly unlikely under normal market conditions, and the exam will rarely present such an extreme figure.

Below is a concise summary of the usual premium/discount bands observed on MCX and NCDEX. Use this as a quick reference when evaluating numerical questions.

Typical Premium and Discount Ranges by Commodity Category (Indian Markets)

Commodity CategoryTypical Premium (%)Typical Discount (%)
Agricultural (e.g., wheat, pulses)2 – 60 – 2
Metals (e.g., gold, copper)0 – 30 – 1
Energy (e.g., crude oil, natural gas)1 – 40 – 3
Other (e.g., rubber, cotton)0 – 50 – 4

Average Premium Percentage Across Commodity Groups

NISM‑Style Practice Question

Example: Calculating Premium for Gold Futures

Scenario

An investor looks at MCX gold futures that expire in three months. The current spot price of 10‑gram gold is INR 50,000. The quoted futures price for the same contract is INR 51,500. The investor wants to know the premium percentage and the impact on the initial margin.

Solution

Step 1: Use the premium formula: ((F – S) / S) × 100. Substituting, ((51,500 – 50,000) / 50,000) × 100 = (1,500 / 50,000) × 100 = 0.03 × 100 = 3%. Step 2: A 3% premium means the futures price is 3% higher than the spot. If the exchange requires an initial margin of 10% of the futures value, the margin = 10% × 51,500 = INR 5,150 per contract. The premium contributes INR 150 (difference between futures and spot) to the cash‑settlement amount at expiry for the long position.

Conclusion

The gold contract carries a 3% premium, which raises both the futures price and the margin requirement. Recognising the premium helps the candidate answer both the percentage calculation and the margin implication.

ℹ️Memory Aid

Remember the acronym "P‑F‑S": Premium = Futures minus Spot, then divide by Spot, finally multiply by 100.

Regulatory Perspective on Premium/Discount

SEBI’s circulars require brokers and clearing members to disclose the premium or discount on commodity futures in their daily market reports. This transparency helps regulators monitor excessive price differentials that could indicate market manipulation or stress.

Under the risk‑management framework, a higher premium may trigger additional margin buffers, as the clearing corporation views it as a sign of increased financing cost or potential price volatility. Conversely, a deep discount can lead to heightened surveillance for possible short‑squeeze scenarios.

For the NISM exam, be prepared to answer questions on how SEBI expects participants to report premium/discount and how it influences margin policy. The key point is that premium/discount is not just a calculation—it directly feeds into regulatory compliance and risk controls.

Exam Takeaways

  • Premium = (Futures – Spot) ÷ Spot × 100; a positive result indicates a premium, negative indicates a discount.
  • Use spot price as the denominator; swapping the terms reverses the sign and leads to a common exam error.
  • Premium reflects cost of carry and financing; discount often appears for seasonal agricultural commodities.
  • Higher premiums increase initial margin requirements, while discounts may raise risk‑based margin buffers.
  • SEBI mandates daily reporting of premium/discount and uses it to adjust margin policies and monitor market health.

Practice Questions

7 questions on Premium Discount

1

In commodity futures, a premium occurs when

2

Which formula correctly calculates the premium or discount percentage?

3

Spot price of a commodity is INR 1,800 and the futures price is INR 1,890. What is the premium/discount percentage?

4

If the futures price is INR 950 and the spot price is INR 1,000, which statement is correct?

5

An investor sees a gold futures price of INR 51,500 and a spot price of INR 50,000. If the exchange requires an initial margin of 10% of the futures value, what is the margin amount and the cash‑settlement premium component?

6

Under SEBI regulations, a higher premium on a commodity futures contract typically leads the clearing corporation to:

7

Which commodity category is most likely to exhibit a premium of up to 3% under normal market conditions in Indian markets?

Related topics