Bonus Stripping
Bonus stripping is a tax planning technique that involves the sale of bonus shares separately from the original shares. It matters for the NISM exam because candidates must know the tax implications and how to compute capital gains on bonus shares. Understanding this concept helps investment advisers advise clients on optimal holding periods and tax efficiency.
Learning Objectives
- 1Define bonus stripping and its purpose
- 2Explain the tax treatment of bonus shares under Indian law
- 3Calculate capital gains arising from bonus stripping
- 4Identify holding‑period rules and common exam pitfalls
What is Bonus Stripping?
Bonus stripping refers to the practice of selling bonus shares that arise from a corporate bonus issue while retaining the original shares. The investor typically purchases the equity before the bonus issue, receives bonus shares at no cost, and then sells the bonus portion to realise a capital gain.
The key idea is that the cost of acquisition for bonus shares is deemed to be zero under the Income Tax Act. Consequently, any sale proceeds from the bonus shares are treated as pure capital gains, which can be taxed at the short‑term or long‑term rates depending on the holding period.
For the NISM exam, you must recognise that bonus stripping is not a prohibited activity; it is a legitimate tax‑saving strategy, provided the adviser discloses it to the client and complies with SEBI’s suitability norms.
- Bonus shares are issued in a predetermined ratio (e.g., 1:1, 2:1) and are credited to the shareholder’s demat account automatically.
- The original shares and bonus shares can be sold in separate transactions, each attracting its own tax treatment.
Many candidates mistakenly assign the original purchase price to bonus shares. The correct rule is that the cost of acquisition for bonus shares is zero, which directly impacts the capital‑gain calculation.
Tax Treatment of Bonus Shares
When bonus shares are sold, the Income Tax Act treats them as a separate asset with a cost base of ₹0. Therefore, the entire sale consideration (minus transaction expenses) is taxable as capital gain.
If the bonus shares are sold within 12 months of receipt, the gain is classified as short‑term capital gain (STCG) and taxed at a flat 15% (plus applicable surcharge and cess). If the holding period exceeds 12 months, the gain qualifies as long‑term capital gain (LTCG) and is taxed at 10% on the amount exceeding the annual exemption of ₹1 lakh.
These rates apply irrespective of the investor’s ordinary income tax slab, making bonus stripping attractive for high‑income clients who would otherwise face a higher marginal rate on ordinary income.
Tax rates applicable to gains from original shares vs. bonus shares
| Asset Type | Holding Period | Tax Rate | Key Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original Shares | ≤ 12 months | 15% (STCG) | Cost of acquisition is the purchase price |
| Original Shares | > 12 months | 10% on gains > ₹1 Lakh (LTCG) | Cost of acquisition is the purchase price |
| Bonus Shares | ≤ 12 months | 15% (STCG) | Cost of acquisition is ₹0 |
| Bonus Shares | > 12 months | 10% on gains > ₹1 Lakh (LTCG) | Cost of acquisition is ₹0 |
Capital Gains Calculation for Bonus Stripping
Where:
CG= Capital gain (₹)S= Sale consideration received for bonus shares (₹)C= Cost of acquisition of bonus shares (₹) – always 0E= Expenses incurred on sale (brokerage, STT, etc.) (₹)Worked Example
Given S = 55,000, C = 0, E = 500: Step 1: CG = 55,000 - 0 - 500 Step 2: CG = 54,500 Verification: 55,000 - 0 - 500 = 54,500.
The formula above is the standard capital‑gain computation prescribed by the Income Tax Act. Because the cost of acquisition for bonus shares is zero, the entire sale proceeds (after deducting brokerage and other expenses) become taxable.
Advisers should always collect the exact brokerage amount (E) to avoid over‑ or under‑stating the gain. The tax payable is then obtained by applying the appropriate STCG or LTCG rate to the CG figure.
Remember that the 10% LTCG rate applies only after the aggregate LTCG in a financial year exceeds the exemption limit of ₹1 lakh. If the client’s total LTCG from all equity holdings is below this threshold, no tax is due even after a profitable bonus‑stripping transaction.
Scenario
Rohan bought 1,000 shares of XYZ Ltd. at ₹50 each on 1 Jan 2022. On 1 Oct 2022, XYZ announced a 1:1 bonus issue, crediting 1,000 bonus shares to Rohan’s demat account on 1 Nov 2022. Rohan sold the 1,000 bonus shares on 15 Nov 2022 at ₹55 per share, paying a brokerage of ₹500.
Solution
Step 1: Compute sale consideration S = 1,000 × 55 = ₹55,000. Step 2: Cost of acquisition C = ₹0 (bonus shares). Step 3: Expenses E = ₹500. Step 4: Capital gain CG = 55,000 - 0 - 500 = ₹54,500. Step 5: Holding period is less than 12 months, so STCG rate = 15%. Tax payable = 0.15 × 54,500 = ₹8,175. Since the gain is short‑term, the ₹1 Lakh LTCG exemption does not apply.
Conclusion
Rohan’s bonus‑stripping transaction generated a taxable short‑term capital gain of ₹54,500, resulting in a tax liability of ₹8,175. The example illustrates the zero‑cost basis and the importance of the holding‑period rule.
Students often aggregate the sale proceeds of original and bonus shares and apply a single cost base. Always treat the two sets of shares separately; the original shares retain their purchase cost, while bonus shares have a cost of zero.
Holding‑Period Implications
The tax rate applied to the gain from bonus shares hinges on the holding period counted from the date of receipt of the bonus shares. If the bonus shares are sold within 12 months, the gain is short‑term and taxed at 15%.
If the investor holds the bonus shares for more than 12 months, the gain becomes long‑term and is taxed at 10% on the amount exceeding the ₹1 Lakh exemption. This can significantly reduce tax outflow for high‑value transactions.
Advisers should therefore counsel clients on the optimal timing of the sale: a short‑term sale may be preferable when the client needs liquidity and is comfortable with the 15% rate, while a long‑term sale is advantageous for tax efficiency if the client can wait.
Tax Payable on Bonus Shares – Short‑Term vs Long‑Term
Practical Steps for Investment Advisers
1. Identify Bonus Eligibility: Verify the bonus issue ratio, record date, and entitlement date for each client’s holdings.
2. Separate Transaction Records: Maintain distinct purchase‑sale logs for original shares and bonus shares to ensure correct cost bases.
3. Calculate Expected Tax: Use the capital‑gain formula to project tax liability under both short‑term and long‑term scenarios. Present the comparison to the client.
4. Compliance Check: Ensure that the recommendation complies with SEBI’s suitability obligations and that the client’s risk profile aligns with the timing of the sale.
5. Documentation: Record the advice, calculations, and client acknowledgment in the advisory file for audit purposes.
⭐Exam Takeaways
- Bonus stripping involves selling bonus shares separately; the cost of acquisition for bonus shares is ₹0.
- STCG on bonus shares (≤12 months) is taxed at a flat 15%; LTCG (>12 months) is taxed at 10% on gains above ₹1 Lakh.
- Capital gain = Sale consideration – Cost of acquisition (₹0) – Sale expenses; apply the appropriate tax rate.
- Always keep original and bonus share transactions separate to avoid mis‑calculating cost bases.
- Advisers must disclose the strategy, verify client suitability, and retain detailed documentation.
Practice Questions
8 questions on Bonus Stripping
What is bonus stripping?
Under the Income Tax Act, what is the cost of acquisition for bonus shares?
Rohan sold bonus shares for a total consideration of ₹80,000 and incurred brokerage of ₹1,000. The holding period exceeds 12 months. What is the tax payable on this transaction?
When both original and bonus shares are sold within 12 months, which statement is correct?
Rohan bought 500 shares at ₹40 each. A 1:1 bonus issued 500 bonus shares. He sold the original shares after 14 months at ₹45 each, paying ₹400 brokerage, and sold the bonus shares after 10 months at ₹45 each, paying ₹300 brokerage. What is the total tax payable?
The holding period for determining the tax character of a gain on bonus shares starts from which date?
What common exam mistake relates to the cost of bonus shares?
Is bonus stripping prohibited under Indian securities regulations?
