3.3

Comparison between Insurance Policies

This sub-topic deals with the systematic comparison of various non‑life insurance policies offered in India. Understanding how policies differ in coverage, premium structures, benefits, and charges is essential for answering scenario‑based questions in the NISM Series X‑B exam. The content links directly to the module on Non‑Life Insurance Products and equips you to select the most suitable policy for a client.

Learning Objectives

  • 1Identify the major types of non‑life insurance policies and their core features.
  • 2Compare policies on the basis of premium payment options, benefit payouts, and charges.
  • 3Analyse policy suitability using client profiling criteria.
  • 4Avoid common exam traps related to policy terminology and exclusions.

Major Types of Non‑Life Insurance Policies

Term Insurance provides pure life cover for a fixed period. The sum assured is paid only on death during the term, with no maturity benefit.

Endowment Policies combine life cover with a savings component. If the policyholder survives the policy term, a maturity benefit (usually the sum assured plus bonuses) is paid.

Unit‑Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs) link the investment portion to market‑linked funds, offering both protection and market‑linked returns. The fund value fluctuates with market performance.

Health (Mediclaim) Policies cover medical expenses incurred due to hospitalization, surgery, or day‑care procedures. They are distinct from life cover policies.

  • Motor Insurance – compulsory for vehicles, covers third‑party liability and optional own‑damage.
  • Home Insurance – protects against fire, natural calamities, and theft.

Key Features to Compare Across Policies

When comparing policies, the first dimension is the coverage scope. Some policies, like term, focus solely on death benefit, whereas health policies address medical costs. Understanding what is covered versus what is excluded is critical for client suitability.

The second dimension is the premium structure. Policies may offer single premium, regular (annual, semi‑annual, quarterly, monthly), or limited‑pay options. The premium amount is influenced by age, sum assured, policy term, and underwriting class.

Third, examine the benefit payout mechanics. For endowment and ULIP, the maturity benefit may include bonuses or fund value, while health policies have claim limits per year and per hospitalization. The timing of claim settlement (speed) also varies and is examined in the exam.

Finally, consider policy‑specific exclusions and waiting periods. Many health policies have a 30‑day waiting period for pre‑existing diseases, and term policies may exclude death due to suicide within the first year. Overlooking these can lead to wrong answer choices.

ℹ️Exam Trap – Sum Assured vs. Maturity Benefit

Students often assume the sum assured equals the maturity amount for endowment policies. In reality, the maturity benefit includes the sum assured plus accrued bonuses, which can be significant.

Premium Payment Options

Insurance companies typically allow four premium payment modes: single premium, regular premium (payable annually, semi‑annually, quarterly, or monthly), limited‑pay (e.g., pay for 10 years on a 20‑year policy), and pay‑as‑you‑earn for ULIPs where premiums are linked to the fund purchase.

Regular premium options affect the policy's cash value and surrender value. A higher frequency (monthly) usually carries a slight loading compared to annual payments because of increased administrative cost.

From an exam perspective, remember that the premium frequency does not change the sum assured, but it does affect the total outflow and may influence the policy's suitability for cash‑flow‑constrained clients.

Comparison of Premium Structures Across Common Non‑Life Policies

Policy TypePremium Payment ModeTypical Sum Assured Range (₹)Claim Settlement Ratio (%)
Term InsuranceSingle / Regular (Annual, Semi‑annual, Quarterly, Monthly)1,00,000 – 5,00,00095
Endowment PolicyRegular (Annual, Semi‑annual)2,00,000 – 10,00,00092
ULIPRegular / Limited‑pay / Pay‑as‑you‑earn5,00,000 – 20,00,00090
Health (Mediclaim)Annual50,000 – 3,00,00094

Benefit Payouts and Claim Settlement

Death benefit in term and endowment policies is the sum assured, whereas ULIPs pay the fund value at the time of claim, which may be higher or lower than the original sum assured depending on market performance.

Health policies pay actual medical expenses up to the sum insured, subject to sub‑limits for room rent, ICU, etc. The claim process usually requires submission of hospital bills and a claim form within a stipulated period.

Claim settlement speed is a crucial comparison metric. Faster settlement enhances client satisfaction and is often highlighted in IRDAI disclosures. The exam may ask you to identify the policy with the quickest settlement based on given data.

Average Claim Settlement Time (Days) by Policy Type

Policy Charges and Expenses

Every policy carries charges that affect its overall cost. Common charges include policy administration charge, premium allocation charge (especially for ULIPs), mortality loading based on health risk, and surrender charge if the policy is terminated early.

ULIPs also have a fund management fee expressed as a percentage of assets under management. These fees are deducted from the fund value and can erode returns over time.

For the exam, be able to identify which charge applies to which policy type and how it influences the net benefit to the policyholder.

Formula: Loss Ratio (Industry Benchmark)
Claims PaidEarned Premium×100\frac{\text{Claims Paid}}{\text{Earned Premium}} \times 100

Where:

Claims Paid= Total amount paid by the insurer for claims during the period (₹)
Earned Premium= Premium earned by the insurer for the same period (₹)

Worked Example

Given Claims Paid = 9,00,000 and Earned Premium = 12,00,000: Step 1: Loss Ratio = (9,00,000 ÷ 12,00,000) × 100 Step 2: Loss Ratio = 0.75 × 100 = 75% Verification: (9,00,000 ÷ 12,00,000) × 100 = 75%.

⚠️Common Mistake – Ignoring Policy Exclusions

Students frequently overlook the exclusion clause and assume full coverage. Always read the exclusions; for example, most health policies exclude cosmetic surgery and pre‑existing conditions within the waiting period.

Suitability and Client Profiling

Matching a policy to a client requires assessing age, income, risk appetite, and financial goals. Younger clients with high income may benefit from term insurance for pure protection, while middle‑aged clients seeking savings may prefer endowment or ULIP.

For health coverage, the client’s medical history, family size, and expected hospitalisation frequency guide the choice of sum insured and waiting period.

In the NISM exam, scenario questions often provide client details and ask you to recommend the most appropriate policy type based on the comparison criteria discussed.

Example: Scenario – Choosing Between Term and Endowment for a 30‑Year‑Old

Scenario

Rohit, 30 years old, earns ₹12 lakh per annum. He wants to protect his family and also build a corpus for his child's education in 15 years. He can afford a premium of up to ₹15,000 per year.

Solution

Step 1: Calculate required death cover. A common rule is 10‑12 times annual income, so Rohit needs ₹1.2 crore coverage. A term policy for ₹1.2 crore with a 15‑year term costs roughly ₹14,500 per year, fitting his budget. Step 2: Assess endowment option. An endowment with the same sum assured and term would cost about ₹30,000 per year, exceeding his premium limit. Step 3: Since his primary need is protection and he can meet the education corpus through other savings, the term policy is the most suitable recommendation.

Conclusion

The example illustrates how premium affordability, coverage need, and savings goal drive the policy selection. Remember that term policies provide higher pure protection for a given premium.

Regulatory Disclosures and IRDAI Guidelines

IRDAI mandates that insurers disclose the policy wording, premium breakdown, claim settlement ratio, and any waiting periods in the policy brochure. These disclosures help investors compare policies objectively.

The regulator also requires a standard Key Features Summary that lists coverage, exclusions, premium mode, and surrender values. Failure to present these details can lead to regulatory penalties.

For the exam, be prepared to identify which document contains the required disclosures and how they assist in policy comparison.

Exam Takeaways

  • Term, Endowment, ULIP, and Health policies differ fundamentally in coverage, benefit payout, and premium structure.
  • Premium payment modes (single, regular, limited‑pay) affect cash flow but not the sum assured; higher frequency adds a small loading.
  • Key comparison metrics include claim settlement ratio, settlement time, policy charges, and exclusions.
  • Loss Ratio = (Claims Paid ÷ Earned Premium) × 100 is a standard industry measure to gauge profitability and claim experience.
  • Always read the exclusion clause; common exam traps involve assuming full coverage for all medical conditions.
  • Match policy type to client profile: protection for young earners, savings component for middle‑aged, health cover based on family medical history.
  • IRDAI requires clear disclosure of policy features, charges, and claim settlement data – essential for transparent comparison.

Practice Questions

8 questions on Comparison between Insurance Policies

1

Which of the following best describes term insurance?

2

Which premium payment mode is NOT mentioned as commonly allowed by insurance companies?

3

Based on the comparison table, which policy type has the highest claim settlement ratio?

4

For which policy does the maturity benefit typically include the sum assured plus accrued bonuses?

5

If an insurer paid claims of ₹6,00,000 and earned premiums of ₹10,00,000, what is the loss ratio?

6

Rohit, 30 years old, earns ₹12 lakh per annum and can pay up to ₹15,000 premium per year. He wants protection for his family and to build a corpus for his child’s education in 15 years. Which policy is most suitable?

7

Which policy type has the shortest average claim settlement time according to the chart?

8

Which of the following charges is specifically associated with ULIP policies?

Related topics